Showing posts with label work identity. Show all posts
Showing posts with label work identity. Show all posts

Tuesday, 10 November 2009

Personal Fulfilment: In the Workplace?

At the recent Battle of Ideas conference work strand ‘The changing meaning of work – from work-life balance to unemployment’, Stephen Overell from the Work Foundation suggested that meaningful work had shifted from the purely economic sense of ‘a fair day’s work for a fair day’s pay’ or the broader vocational sense of public service to something more subjective - a quest for personal fulfilment that is not necessarily progressive.

He sees this new inwardness in how we see work as a reflection of the gradual evolution of social values: greater affluence, education, rapid rise in professional and managerial work in the 20th century and a dominant culture of expressive individualism.

Finding satisfaction in one’s work is not new. A job well done, whether it’s stacking shelves, maintaining a well kept filing system or producing a well crafted report can give one immense satisfaction. Having a good employer, likeable colleagues and a nice working environment make work a pleasanter place to be but none of these things provide that sense of fulfilment we seem to crave today.

Craftsmen or artists may come closer to a sense of personal self-expression and fulfilment in what they do. Not long ago, a sense of vocation – a calling to public service – provided an adequate sense of fulfilment for many nurses, doctors, teachers, social workers or civil servants.

So what’s changed?

Stephen Overell sees the loss of meaning increasing since the 1970’s with the decline in the concept of vocation, the ethos of public service and self-sacrifice. Without this meaning can seem ‘self-interested and solipsistic’ and the search for meaning in work today is therefore not necessarily progressive.

I agree with Stephen about the loss of the ethos of public service but I also believe that this is linked to a bigger picture: the narrowing of the public space in which people were able to find fulfilment and meaning beyond the limitations of the workplace.

During the 1980’s and early 1990’s, I and my colleagues were involved in political campaigns: in support of the miners and Irish Freedom, against racism and imperialist wars, for womens rights and abortion on demand. At work we organised around the trade unions in town halls and on picket lines.
Our identities were defined by our political ideals. Personal fulfilment was a collective endeavour.

One may have shuffled papers or stacked shelves at work but outside of work, one could be addressing a rally, organising a march or protest or being interviewed on the television or radio.

Work was a material means to a more fulfilling end. Perhaps we need to recreate our public space with new visions of the society we want and forget about trying to seek personal fulfilment at work.

Thursday, 18 June 2009

The Knox Man-Work and Identity

"All I want is to get enough dough coming in to keep us solvent for the next year or so , till I can figure things out; meanwhile I want to retain my own identity. Therefore the thing I'm most anxious to avoid is any kind of work that can be considered 'interesting' in it's own right. I want something that can't possibly touch me."

"I mean the great advantage of a place like Knox is that you can sort of turn off your mind every morning at nine and leave it off all day, and nobody knows the difference."

So boasts Frank Wheeler in
'Revolutionary Road', the novel by Richard Yates recently made into a critically acclaimed film.

It's the sort of sentiment those who work in large corporate structures whether private or public may empathize with. Many may boast about it's easy, stress-free flexibility and yet as time passes and they find themselves still there, they, like Frank Wheeler, become slightly more embarrassed about telling people what they do for a living because it sounds rather dull and uninteresting.

So what keeps us tied to places of work like these?

I think most of us would agree with Frank when he says it's 'the people' he would miss if he had to quit.

"I mean hell, they're a pretty decent crowd; some of them anyway."

And there are other things too: the homely feeling of a familiar place and the 'ways of spacing out the hours of the day - almost time to go down for coffee; almost time to go out for lunch; almost time to go home –.'

An added interest is the odd office flirtation at the Christmas party or in the filing room.

For an in depth and entertaining look at positive aspects of work see
Alain de Botton's The Pleasures and Sorrows of Work.

And yet there is something lacking. There doesn't seem to be any purpose in a job like this. Even when Frank Wheeler accidentally lands a project, it lacks real meaning - it's just another smooth talking sales promotion campaign.

However, the idea of escaping from this meaningless reality to the imagined artistic-intellectual milieu of Paris to write a novel while his wife gets a job to pay for their keep seems daunting and eventually even a little insane. Is it really the job preventing Frank's writing a novel or has he really got it in him to be a writer? These are the doubts that haunt those of us in dull, safe, meaningless jobs. Perhaps, as Frank decides, it's better to stay and earn a living, try to get a raise in order to afford a bigger house and holidays abroad rather than having to relocate and begin anew.

On the other hand, just working provides a sense of purpose for his neighbour – Mrs. Helen Givings. For most of her life she worked as an admin assistant in the Horst Ball Bearing Company.

' "It certainly can't be very interesting," her husband would say, "and it certainly isn't as if we needed the money. Why, then?" '

' "Because I love it," she'd said. 'Deep down what she loved and needed was work itself.'

' "Hard work," her father always said, "is the best medicine yet for all the ills of man - and of woman," and she'd always believed it. The press and bustle and glare of the office, the quick lunch sent up on a tray, the crisp handling of papers and telephones, the exhaustion of staying overtime and the final sweet relief of slipping off her shoes at night, which left her feeling drained and pure and fit for nothing but two aspirins and a hot bath and a light supper and bed - '

So, is it really the work itself that is the problem or our expectations of what work should be - or maybe the expectations others in society have of the work we do?

If work gives us an identity is it the identity we want?

Can we have a separate identity outside of the work we do?